Skip to content
Log in Sign up
Cart (0) Check Out

critical EYE Finds

lovely & unusual things to delight, inspire & surprise

>>> NEW listings sundays, 4p ET

NOTE: This is the ONLY authentic critical eye finds website. There is a fake website that has copied listings of long since sold products -- it is not my site, and I have reported it!

Also note: items in your cart are NOT secured. Others may still purchase them until you have fully completed check out.


  • just in
  • everything in stock
  • overlooked gems (kate's picks)
  • things to hang
  • objects
  • the menagerie (animals!)
  • little treats ($50 & under)
  • clearance (marked way down)
  • complete sold archive
  • home
  • about
  • shop policies (I want you to be happy!)
  • gift cards
  • critical eye findings (blog)
  • Log in
  • Sign up
  • Facebook
  • Instagram


Home › Stocking Stuffers (or Little Pick Me Ups)

Stocking Stuffers (or Little Pick Me Ups)

A Present for Esther MClure, Charming Antique Needlepoint Love Token Bookmark
A Present for Esther MClure, Charming Antique Needlepoint Love Token Bookmark
Regular price $45.00
Moody Sixteenth Plate Tintype of Moody Young Boy
Moody Sixteenth Plate Tintype of Moody Young Boy
Regular price $15.00
Retro-Futuro Homemade Green and Silver Painted Wooden Toy Car
Retro-Futuro Homemade Green and Silver Painted Wooden Toy Car
Regular price $30.00 — Sold Out
Young Man with Horse and Barn, Thurman, NY, Antique Snapshot
Young Man with Horse and Barn, Thurman, NY, Antique Snapshot
Regular price $15.00
A (Much Loved) Token of Love, Scarce Early (1820s) Creamware Child's Mug with Sweet Old Repairs
A (Much Loved) Token of Love, Scarce Early (1820s) Creamware Child's Mug with Sweet Old Repairs
Regular price $75.00 — Sold Out
c. 1940s Celluloid "Dainty Dominoes" Double Nines Set (3 Missing)
c. 1940s Celluloid "Dainty Dominoes" Double Nines Set (3 Missing)
Regular price $40.00 — Sold Out
1861 Cover with Poignant Cancellation and Upside Down Year: New York to Stoughton, MA
1861 Cover with Poignant Cancellation and Upside Down Year: New York to Stoughton, MA
Regular price $25.00
c. 1970 White with Green Stripe "Classy Cap" Paper Hats (Two Lots of 8 Available)
c. 1970 White with Green Stripe "Classy Cap" Paper Hats (Two Lots of 8 Available)
Regular price $10.00
P.A. Baker, Silver Foil and Reverse Painted Glass Nameplate with Scalloped Edge
P.A. Baker, Silver Foil and Reverse Painted Glass Nameplate with Scalloped Edge
Regular price $30.00
Nailed Up Pin Ups, Unusual Old Snapshot Photo
Nailed Up Pin Ups, Unusual Old Snapshot Photo
Regular price $30.00
Queen of the Ducks, Old Snapshot Photo
Queen of the Ducks, Old Snapshot Photo
Regular price $12.00 — Sold Out
Make Do Scrap Tin Fish Shaped Cookie Cutter
Make Do Scrap Tin Fish Shaped Cookie Cutter
Regular price $35.00
« Previous 1 2 3 4 5 … 10 Next »

Get in touch!

Please contact me at 816.522.6024 or criticaleyellc@gmail.com with questions, comments, to request more images of anything you see, request alternative shipping options, or just to say hello! I'd especially love feedback and photos of your finds in their new homes! 

Be in the know


Copyright © 2025, critical EYE Finds. Powered by Shopify
Payment icons
  • American Express
  • Apple Pay
  • Diners Club
  • Discover
  • Google Pay
  • Mastercard
  • PayPal
  • Shop Pay
  • Visa